Les archives du Forum Catholique
Forum | Documents | Liens | Q.F.P. | Oremus

Les archives du Forum Catholique

JUIN 2001 A JUILLET 2003

Retour à la liste des messages | Rechercher

Afficher le fil complet

Désaccord sur un point Imprimer
Auteur : Ioannes
Sujet : Désaccord sur un point
Date : 2003-06-06 11:20:39

Là, je ne suis pas d'accord. Car, si les diverses modalités possibles sont nombreuses, il faut bien à la FSSPX un cadre juridique exprimant et défendant cette réalité essentielle : il existe un nouveau rit, essentiellement différent du nouveau. Je dis bien : rit - un ensemble de livres liturgiques, calendrier, coutumes, législations etc. Ce nouveau rit est incompatible avec l'ancien rit latin. Tout comme il l'est avec les rits orientaux. Ceci, il faut bien que le cadre canonique en tienne compte. Non ?


La discussion

      Item (4 juin), de Matthieu (80.9.226.xxx) [2003-06-05 09:43:49]
          Juridique toujours, de Edouard [2003-06-05 10:16:32]
              - pdt -, de Michel R [2003-06-05 10:35:32]
              Re : Juridique toujours, de Rikiki (212.157.126.xxx) [2003-06-05 11:26:21]
                  oui mais, de Adso (212.234.180.xxx) [2003-06-05 11:31:00]
                      Dubitatif, de Ioannes [2003-06-05 14:41:33]
                          - pdt -, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-05 15:28:46]
                          Irrégulier ?, de Edouard [2003-06-05 15:39:32]
                              Re : Irrégulier ?, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-05 16:33:14]
                                  Vrai mais, de Edouard [2003-06-05 17:18:15]
                                      Ordre, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-05 17:24:24]
                                      Bravo pour le niveau des arguments, de NB (194.117.217.xxx) [2003-06-05 17:24:25]
                                          Laissez Justin, de Edouard [2003-06-06 09:10:15]
                                              Désaccord sur un point, de Ioannes [2003-06-06 11:20:39]
                                                  Et alors ?, de Edouard [2003-06-06 11:25:46]
                                                      Voici la raison..., de Ioannes [2003-06-06 12:21:22]
                                                          Et alors ?, de Edouard [2003-06-06 15:18:05]
                                                              Alors, alors..., de Ioannes [2003-06-06 15:22:29]
                                                                  Joie des uns, de Edouard [2003-06-06 15:32:09]
                                                                      provocation, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-06 16:00:27]
                                                                          C'est pas catholique, de Edouard [2003-06-06 16:09:44]
                                                                              La porte est ouverte, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-06 16:28:15]
                                      Notitiae, de Ioannes [2003-06-05 20:38:44]
                                          Administration ou pas ?, de Edouard [2003-06-06 09:17:51]
                                              Questions de fond, de Ioannes [2003-06-06 11:13:49]
                                                  C'est de la politique, de Edouard [2003-06-06 11:24:08]
                                                      Prouvez ce que vous dites !, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-06 12:06:33]
                                                          Merci pour l'exemple !, de Edouard [2003-06-06 14:30:46]
                                                              Campos, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-06 14:40:49]
                                                                  En droit, non; en pratique, oui, de Edouard [2003-06-06 15:14:05]
                                                                      OK mais pas de généralisation de cet [...], de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-06 15:55:05]
                                                      2 formes d'optimisme erroné ?, de Ioannes [2003-06-06 12:30:59]
                                                          Irrégulier, mais secondaire., de Edouard [2003-06-06 14:33:31]
                                                              Des saints prêtres contre la crise, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-06 14:46:01]
                                                                  Déjà vu, de Edouard [2003-06-06 15:10:05]
                                                                      actuellement non évidemment, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-06 15:29:34]
                                                              Ioannes précise sa pensée..., de Ioannes [2003-06-06 14:57:29]
                                                                  Il vous semble bien, de Edouard [2003-06-06 15:11:55]
                                                                      Sumus d'accord [NT], de Ioannes [2003-06-06 15:13:50]
                              Mise au point, de Ioannes [2003-06-05 20:30:38]
                                  Bonne nuance, de Edouard [2003-06-06 09:13:12]
                                      Je vois..., de Ioannes [2003-06-06 11:05:01]
                                  - pdt -, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-06 10:25:04]
                  quelques faits, de Edouard [2003-06-05 11:37:46]
                  Accord [NT], de Ioannes [2003-06-05 14:40:57]
              Donnez nous beaucoup de saint prêtres, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-05 11:58:09]
                  Excellentes questions!!!, de von Loustique (62.147.210.xxx) [2003-06-05 12:40:31]
                      Professeurs hététiques ?, de geronimo (195.93.72.xxx) [2003-06-05 13:16:47]
                          crise de l'autorité, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-05 13:54:55]
                              Re : crise de l'autorité, de geronimo (195.93.72.xxx) [2003-06-05 14:19:06]
                                  excomunication des hérétiques, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-05 14:38:42]
                                      Mélanges..... !!!!!, de geronimo (195.93.72.xxx) [2003-06-05 14:44:55]
                                          Re : Mélanges..... !!!!!, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-05 14:50:42]
                                              Re : Mélanges 2... !!!, de geronimo (195.93.72.xxx) [2003-06-05 14:57:15]
                                                  ?, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-05 15:25:10]
                                      Evangiles, de geronimo (195.93.72.xxx) [2003-06-05 14:51:51]
                                          Voilà !, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-05 14:57:00]
                                              Re : Voilà !, de geronimo (195.93.72.xxx) [2003-06-05 15:04:53]
                                                  Relisez la Genèse !, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-05 15:13:37]
                                                      N'importe quoi [NT], de geronimo (195.93.72.xxx) [2003-06-05 15:20:15]
                                                          L'ancoen testament :" n'importe quoi", de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-05 15:27:05]
                                                              Attendez-là ! [NT], de geronimo (195.93.72.xxx) [2003-06-05 16:29:16]
                                                              Attendez-là !, de geronimo (195.93.72.xxx) [2003-06-05 16:45:02]
                                                                  le bienheureux Pie IX et Géronimo, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-05 17:07:22]
                                                                      Catholique vous ?, de geronimo (195.93.72.xxx) [2003-06-05 18:03:32]
                                                                          5 Sivan, 5763, de geronimo (195.93.74.xxx) [2003-06-05 18:33:52]
                                                                          Petit test de catholicité, de EA (82.65.219.xxx) [2003-06-05 21:07:53]
                                                                              Rebelote.. mais pas dix de der !, de geronimo (195.93.72.xxx) [2003-06-05 21:18:48]
                                                                                  Rebelote.. mais pas dix de der !, de geronimo (195.93.72.xxx) [2003-06-05 21:22:54]
                                                                                      et Saint Pie X, de EA (82.65.219.xxx) [2003-06-05 21:28:44]
                                                                                          Saint ? non, pécheur., de geronimo (195.93.72.xxx) [2003-06-05 21:41:16]
                                                                                  Vous n'approuvez pas les condamnations, de EA (82.65.219.xxx) [2003-06-05 21:23:28]
                                                                                      Inquisiteur, de geronimo (195.93.72.xxx) [2003-06-05 21:34:33]
                                                                                          Re : Inquisiteur, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-06 10:44:08]
                                                                          Ushuaia, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-06 10:57:14]
                                                                  Mais faut-il comprendre ..., de PGM (216.162.67.xxx) [2003-06-06 03:19:56]
                                                          Oui, n'importe quoi!, de Monique (81.51.163.xxx) [2003-06-05 22:52:46]
                                                              Et..., de GDB [2003-06-06 01:07:36]
                                                              Absolument ! [NT], de geronimo (195.93.74.xxx) [2003-06-06 08:42:23]
                                                              Abraham et le Lévitique, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-06 11:11:07]
                  Mauvaises questions, de Edouard [2003-06-05 14:32:18]
                      Marketting religieux, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-05 14:45:55]
                          Cas particulier, de Edouard [2003-06-05 14:49:50]
                              exclu de quoi ?, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-05 14:54:59]
                          Séminaire orthodoxe ?, de geronimo (195.93.72.xxx) [2003-06-05 15:08:16]
                              orthodoxe, de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-05 15:15:23]
                                  Re : orthodoxe, de geronimo (195.93.72.xxx) [2003-06-05 15:21:45]
                                      ? [NT], de EA (194.250.124.xxx) [2003-06-05 15:23:14]
          Re : Item (4 juin), de Vere [2003-06-07 06:08:50]